PhysioMSK

Rigid Carbon Insole

Ad: most product links on this site are affiliate links. We earn a commission if you buy through them, at no extra cost to you. See our affiliate disclosure for details.

This is a super slim, super rigid insole that fits underneath your regular insole, essentially giving you a rigid sole that won’t flex at the forefoot. That makes it great for forefoot MTP joint pain, and especially for hallux rigidus and hallux limitus (arthritis of the big toe MTP joint).

Sometimes you can’t wear rocker-soled shoes for everything. You might need to wear a golf shoe or a formal dress shoe, and this insole can help you wear those shoes in comfort.

What I like

  • Very thin (about 1.3 mm), so it doesn’t take up much room in the shoe
  • Very rigid, so the forefoot barely bends
  • Fits under your usual insole or orthotic, so you keep your cushioning
  • Lets you wear dress shoes, golf shoes and other everyday shoes without the toe joint bending
  • Comes as a pair, in a range of sizes
  • A good partner to my rocker-sole shoe recommendations

Things to know

  • Check the size carefully. The listing says to measure your insole and choose a carbon insole about 1 cm (0.4 inches) shorter than it. This listing is the 273 mm size, so make sure your link goes to the size selector.
  • It goes under your normal insole, not on top of it. Remove the shoe’s insole, place the carbon plate underneath, and put the insole back on top.
  • It stops the forefoot bending, so your walking will feel stiffer and take a little getting used to. Start with a few hours a day.
  • It needs a shoe with enough room. Check that it doesn’t make the shoe too tight.
  • Rigid insoles reduce movement in the sore joint, but they don’t change the arthritis. Evidence for the best approach is limited, and many people use a mix of insoles, rocker shoes and exercises.
  • If your pain is getting worse, or the toe is red, hot or swollen, get it assessed.

Who it suits: people with big toe arthritis (hallux rigidus or limitus) or other forefoot or MTP joint pain, who need a rigid sole in shoes that don’t have a rocker.

Compare with: my recommended rocker-sole shoes: the Brooks Ghost Max 3 (men’s / women’s), Hoka Bondi 9 (men’s / women’s) and Hoka Clifton (men’s / women’s).

Read my article on hallux rigidus or watch my video.

Scroll to Top